Perhaps - IF the bears believe(d) that Maye and/or Daniels are near, at or above where they rank Caleb Williams. Even then, hard to say, unsubstantiated rumors aside, what the Bears would have received in return to move down 1 or 2 spots. Regardless, unless this is the smokescreen of all smokescreen...

Imo, Justin Fields’ lack of development as a passer made trading back for yet another “haul” unlikely. A struggling 4th year QB with a 5th year option decision looming likely made acquiring a quality oc problematic and set the stage for the kind of QB uncertainty now facing Minnesota and Las Vegas. ...

Jay was imo a far more talented passer than fields - faster release, when he was prepared and dialed in (often an issue with him), a much faster processor. At his worst, he was far more productive than fields quote=Grizzled post_id=378483 time=1711288894 user_id=2351] What would Cutler have done wit...

Imo, this is poles being true to his word - doing his best to “do right by Justin.” Also, per Courtney Cronin, Poles was initially asking for a 2nd and 4th for Justin, and no one was remotely interested. Teams that discussed fields with the Bears only viewed him as a backup. Pittsburgh was the best ...

FWIW, some in the Pittsburgh media are reporting that Wilson is the “unquestioned starter” and that fields is there to “fill out the QB room.” That said, I do agree that Pittsburgh is likely the place where Justin has the best chance to play in the regular season. Curious to see what the Steelers do...

Guessing that poles was serious about “doing right by Justin” by trading him to Pittsburgh, where he has a fighting to get meaningful playing time, rather than some place like Philadelphia, where fields had no shot at unseating Hurts. I (also) wonder if the pending 5th year option hurt his trade val...

Understanding I’m generally wrong about these things… Imo, this move screams “building an infrastructure to support a rookie QB with very high upside as a passer” a lot more than “we’re keeping Justin Fields!!” Justin has many gifts. One of them is not being a prolific passer. He’s one of the league...

Cousins just signed with the Falcons, further limiting the market for Fields

This is old news. Caleb didn’t necessarily “cancel” - they’re rescheduling for after USCs pro day. https://gridironheroics.com/caleb-williams-cancels-visit-chicago-bears/ Its wierd but also makes some sense. But it's still wierd. Honor your obligations. William's surely doeant make liking him easy. ...

Agree to an extent on mechanics - don’t agree on ark strength. Williams and Maye’s arms are as strong or stronger. And no one is close to Williams on off platform throws, particularly downfield. IF that is a video about Fields being traded to the Falcons, 1) I hope he kills it there, 2) I'm 100% on ...

Can’t draw any definitive conclusions imo from the presser. Poles tone and language were different than a year ago AND there’s no real need to drum up additional demand for the #1 pick - it’s already extremely high

Williams extreme confidence can go either way imo. On the negative, we have Jay Cutler, who had maximum confidence/arrogance to the point where he’d continually throw at a DB who had his number, leading to 4 ints by said DB or throwing a ridiculous number of pick sixes. On the positive - there’s Aar...

Imo, two+ things can be true at once. The bears can use more talent on offense AND Justin Fields, in year 3, should have been a more productive per game passer than he was in 2023. The Texans and Packers can use more talent on offense, yet their QBs were far superior passers in 2023 than Justin Fiel...

it’s extremely rare for Biggs - or any beat writer - to be as emphatic as Biggs has been about the QB position. He could be wrong - or perhaps he’s Ryan Poles’ useful idiot - but that seems unlikely. Top beat writers like Biggs, who are around Bear front office and coaching personnel all the time, r...

Imo, no beat writer is more dialed in with the bears than Brad Biggs. When he is emphatic/goes out on a limb, he’s rarely if ever wrong. Is it possible that, as Mike Florio suggests (for some reason, he hates the idea of Caleb Williams in Chicago - more from Williams perspective than the Bears) that...

I don’t believe anyone seriously believes that the Steelers (who seemingly are resistant to considering adding fields) or falcons are “Super Bowl” contenders if they add Justin Fields. A couple of things.. Vick best vs Justin's best ..posted from an X thread.. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GG4ooLRXUAA...

Imo, in a scenario like this, Drake Maye might be the pick. Didn’t have his best season, but seems to have elite traits

I agree, in season, he went from terrible to ok. We saw that same thing happen in 2022. When we look at year over year improvement, there is some as a passer, but not much imo. At the rate he’s ascending, it may take another 3-5 years for him to be a legit nfl passer, not just a player who makes the...

Justin fields likely wouldn’t come close to 4300 yards passing with that group. He might finally cross the 3,000 barrier.,.. While I understand the point you're trying to make, Geno Smith hasn't been playing for 10+ years. He had a 7-year stretch where he started 5 games. The embarrassment I referen...

Will be interesting to see which, if any, teams in the league truly view fields as “ascending.” Elite traits? Absolutely. Truly “ascending?” We’ll see quote=HurricaneBear post_id=370673 time=1707460266 user_id=1019] I cannot for the life of me see the Raiders pairing Fields and Getsy together again....

To be fair, you’re also pushing an agenda - one where that stops just short of fully exonerating fields for his chronic lack of productivity as a passer. Admittedly, I do have an agenda. While fields didn’t have 49er level personnel or Andy Reid calling plays for him in 2023, he had enough talent ar...

Imo, a bit of an indication of what league decision makers may actually think of Justin Fields. Getsy was in the mix for a couple of jobs

Magilla_Gorilla wrote: ↑Sun Feb 04, 2024 12:32 am

FWIW, every GM Brad Biggs has spoken to at the senior bowl is certain that the Bears are taking a QB with the first pick. While Fields doesn’t suck - and he’s a rare athlete and, from all appearances, a great person and fantastic teammate - I’m guessing this decision isn’t particularly difficult, fr...

Imo, the Kingsbury situation, while great for social media meltdowns, is irrelevant. Washington was proceeding as if they weren’t landing the former Cardinal head coach until an apparent contract snag caused him to back out of the Vegas job. This likely doesn’t make them want Caleb “even more! “ sho...

Cowherd, I believe, was speculating

Imo, that likely leads to two more bad losses to the packers and the exit of fields, flus and possibly poles



quote=ramentaschen post_id=369068 time=1706598071 user_id=1280]
I'd rather roll with Fields + Bagent as a back up for one more year and draft a WR or DE stud.
[/quote]

Huge difference - Waldron has a legit track record as a nfl play caller quote=Dardango post_id=369302 time=1706679590 user_id=1162] Honestly (i'm a freak and read through most of this), generally people were very cool on the Getsy hire and it feels like we all talked ourselves into him. And part of ...

Imo, if Caleb Williams is in fact a truly elite prospect with the most upside of any QB in this draft and recent drafts - and a lot of folks who do or have worked as GMs and player personnel execs seem to think so - then you have to take him. Trading down for more picks to take a lesser prospect doe...

Imo, it’s hard to imagine all of these frontline offensive coaches are agreeing to come to Chicago to work with a struggling 4th year QB who may be approaching a prove it season.

True, but it's more than a safe assumption, given that Fields is headed into his 4th season, there's a 5th year option decision looming, along with a decision on whether or not to extend him. I'm guessing that Waldron, and all of the OC interviewees, expressed a belief that they could get more out o...